tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-4395214934672260953.post4236372558562806167..comments2023-11-21T00:19:15.151-08:00Comments on Corrections: Page One: The Cost of Terrorism and Airline SecurityCorrections: Page Onehttp://www.blogger.com/profile/07722760575330998692noreply@blogger.comBlogger2125tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-4395214934672260953.post-10428647462546084482011-03-14T16:34:25.186-07:002011-03-14T16:34:25.186-07:00Corrections largely agrees with your thoughts on t...Corrections largely agrees with your thoughts on take on the efficiency of statistical discrimination. <br /><br />The claim by people who don't like statistical discrimination is that Islamic terrorists will just recruit non-Islamic-looking individuals. It is an open empirical question whether or not this would help Islamic terrorists or Americans more. On the one hand, Americans, both those who would be singled out for profile and those who would not, would likely have faster travel times. <br /><br />The pareto improvement Corrections is trying to illustrate is as follows. Say an innocent individual in Muslim garb could make a choice between clearing the line in front of them and being invasively examined or waiting and having a positive (perhaps high) probability of being invasively examined, they may choose the latter. Everyone cleared from the line would obviously also benefit. If this is the case, all Americans benefit.<br /><br />Do Terrorists benefit? It depends on the cost and difficulty of recruiting non-Islamic looking individuals. Corrections posits this cost is very high, as the FBI has a vast array of white men willing to go undercover. Corrections posits that "random" recruiting of whites for Islamic terrorism will turn up an FBI informant or agent 80% of the time. <br /><br />Even if race isn't used, age crossed with race is likely rather safe to use. As you say, "blue haired grandmothers" and perhaps children, are unlikely to be carrying bombs or be available for carrying bombs. <br /><br />It's unclear whether or not we have actually undergone an erosion of rights as interpreted as the ability to freely choose between different activities. This will perhaps be the basis of a discussion in a future post.Corrections: Page Onehttps://www.blogger.com/profile/06289805130858756309noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-4395214934672260953.post-74902157655817817622011-03-14T16:10:35.834-07:002011-03-14T16:10:35.834-07:00In addition the TSA operations impose a number of ...In addition the TSA operations impose a number of costs. The irradiation of large numbers of Americans - with scanners known to put our more radiation than originally claimed - poses some cancer risk especially for frequent flyers. TSA delays increment travel time - introducing an unpredictable extra obstacle to air travel. More fundamentally though TSA is conditioning Americans to yield their privacy rights, to submit to being groped routinely even though the gropee knows they pose no threat and the TSA gropers are going through the motions. This intrusion is far more negatively impactful against the privacy rights of Americans and their rights not to suffer unreasonable searches and seizures than the much celebrated Guantanamo base sequestering of large numbers of foreign nations apprehended on the battlefield making war against Americans. TSA activities are part of a long term erosion of our liberties that will cause them to disappear with a whimper rather than a bang. If a parent will submit to having their baby or small child's genitalia groped for what the parent knows is not reason, by a government official wearing a uniform, just what limits to inappropriate government intrusion are left? To this point all the attempted Islamofascist plane attacks have been conducted by Muslim males, most of them with recent travel to Yemen, the Sudan, Saudi Arabia or Pakistan - what possible purpose does it serve to grope blue haired grandmothers or children. An intelligent approach to screening focusing more attention on the actual threat group including the question approach the Israelis have found so effective.Anonymousnoreply@blogger.com