Business Employment Dynamics: Where Jobs Losses and Gains Come From

Below, Corrections graphically depicts transformed Business Employment Dynamics data.  The two data series are the proportion of gross job losses generated by closing establishments, rather than contracting establishments (click to enlarge).  Similarly for gross job gains generated by opening establishments, rather than expanding establishments.

Three things seem to jump out of the figure:

• Generally, around 20% of gross job gains and losses come from opening and closing establishments.
• Compared to the proportion of gross job losses that come from closings, generally a higher proportion of gross job gains come from openings.
• There has been a secular downward trend in the impact of closings and openings on employment.

The last point is probably bad news for the U.S. economy.

Business Employment Dynamics: 1992:Q3-2011:Q2

Below, Corrections shows Business Employment Dynamics data from 1992:Q3-2011:Q2.  We index to 1992:Q3=1, from data originally in levels.

• Gross job gains are the total people hired in a quarter (not subtracting losses).  U.S. generally has around 7.6 million total gains in a given quarter.  
• Expansions are businesses that reported more jobs than last quarter.  U.S. generally has around 6.1 million firm expansions in a given quarter.
• Openings are businesses that did not exist in the previous quarter.  U.S. generally has around 1.6 million firm openings in a given quarter.
• Gross job losses are the total separations in a quarter (not adding gains).  U.S. generally has around 7.4 million total losses in a given quarter.
• Contractions are businesses that reported fewer jobs than last quarter.  U.S. generally has around 6.0 million firm contractions in a given quarter.
• Closings are businesses that reported last quarter but are no longer active.  U.S. generally has around 1.5 million closings in a given quarter.

We generally think of having both gross job gains and gross job losses high as creative destruction:  while not much is moving, there's a lot of churn in the economy, generally very good.  We generally think of having both gross job gains and gross job losses low as stagnation or sclerosis:  not much is flowing in the economy.

The 1990's and the Great Recession both show prominently in the figure of BED data, depicted graphically below (click to enlarge).

Business Employment Dynamics: 2010Q3 Release

Here, Corrections displays the recent Business Employment Dynamics data from 2010Q3 in rates.  They come from administrative data.  Gross job gains and gross job losses are clearly defined.  Expansions and contractions give the rate of businesses that either expanded their payrolls or contracted their payrolls, in net.  Openings and closings give the rate of businesses that open or closed their doors that quarter.  See these six time series graphically below (click to enlarge).